Firehouse Subs Sauces- Spice Up Your Sandwich

The different sauces at Firehouse Subs make each visit a new experience. They don’t just make the sandwiches special but a perfect complement with extra flavor. What makes their sauces unique are their secret recipes and standardized ingredients.

From mild and tangy choices to hot sauce options, each has a unique taste. You can use them according to your preference, like on both sides of bread, mixing different sauces to create your flavor, starting with small, then more, and keeping extra sauce on the dipping side.

If I talk about its most liked sauce, many visitors want to purchase Captain Sorensen’s sauce, among other sauces. But before buying any sauce, it is better to try the flavors on your sandwich to have the right idea about it. I also have described some of the most popular Firehouse subs sauces, their unique flavors, and how they increase your dining experience; let’s discuss.

Why Firehouse Subs Sauces Are a Must-Try?

Firehouse Subs has many tasty sauces for their sandwiches. These sauces make their subs taste better and more unique. You can pick hot, sweet, or sour sauces on your sub according to your needs and the flavor you want. Many people love these sauces and come back to get more. Each sauce goes well with different sandwiches on their menu.

Popular Firehouse Subs Sauces

Firehouse Subs has brought back its free Hot Sauce Bar, which features 13 sauces with heat levels ranging from mildest (1) to hottest (10). Here are some of the sauces available:

Captain Sorensen’s Datil Pepper Hot Sauce (Heat Scale: 1)

This sauce is a mild hot sauce at Firehouse Subs. It starts sweet and has a light, spicy kick. Made with ketchup and special Datil peppers, it’s perfect for people who don’t like very spicy food.

Best Pairing: Turkey Bacon Ranch, Hook & Ladder

Bee Sting ® Honey n’ Habanero Pepper Sauce (Heat Scale: 2)

This sweet-hot sauce mixes honey with spicy habanero peppers. First, you taste the sweet honey, then comes the heat. Many people enjoy it because the sweet and spicy flavors work really well together.

Best Pairing: Cajun Chicken, Hook & Ladder

Fat Cat Peach Maple Bourbon Hot Sauce and Glaze (Heat Scale: 2)

This taste of fat cat sauce mixes peaches and maple syrup with bourbon flavor. It’s sweet with a hint of heat. The rich mix of flavors makes your sandwich more interesting and special.

Best Pairing: Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket, Club on a Sub

Backdraft Fire Sauce (Heat Scale: 3)

This yellow sauce starts sweet and ends with a spicy kick. It’s made with mustard and hot peppers. Many people like to add it to their sandwiches for more flavor.

Best Pairing: New York Steamer, Firehouse Meatball

Frank’s RedHot ® Original Cayenne Pepper Hot Sauce (Heat Scale: 3)

A spicy red sauce made from cayenne peppers brings just the right heat. It has a tangy taste that’s not too hot. Most people choose it for a simple, tasty start.

Best Pairing: Turkey & Cranberry

Gator Hammock Gator Sauce (Heat Scale: 3)

The unique combination of red and black pepper flakes mixed with garlic and vinegar for good flavor. It’s medium hot with small pieces of spices, you can see. This makes your sandwich taste even better.

Best Pairing: Italian, Club on a Sub

Hot N Saucy Carrot N Chipotle (Heat Scale: 3)

People who like smoky flavors really enjoy this one. The mix of sweet carrots and smoky peppers makes this sauce special. It has a medium heat and rich smoky taste from adobo sauce.

Best Pairing: Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket, Hook & Ladder

CHA! by Texas Pete ® Sriracha Sauce (Heat Scale: 4)

If you want both sweet and hot tastes try CHA! by Texas Pete ® Sriracha Sauce. It’s made with sriracha and has a gentle heat. Moreover, it is packed with spicy and sweet flavors, this bright red sauce makes any sandwich better.

Best Pairing: Cajun Chicken, Turkey Bacon Ranch

TABASCO ® Brand Green Jalapeño Pepper Sauce (Heat Scale: 4)

With fresh jalapeños and vinegar, this green sauce brings good heat and tang. The spicy peppers make sure the vinegar isn’t too strong. People found it perfect for adding a fresh, hot taste.

Best Pairing: Firehouse Meatball, Club on a Sub

Cholula ® Original Hot Sauce (Heat Scale: 5)

Using Mexican arbol and piquín peppers mixed with spices, this smooth red sauce brings mild heat. It’s not too hot and works well on many different sandwiches.

Best Pairing: Engineer, Hook & Ladder

TABASCO ® Original Red Sauce (Heat Scale: 6)

Made from aged red peppers with vinegar and salt, this classic sauce brings strong heat. It’s a hot sauce that many people choose when they want a good spicy flavor.

Best Pairing: New York Steamer, Italian

Florida Man’s Lunacy Pineapple Hot Sauce (Heat Scale: 7)

If you want something fruity and spicy, this sauce mixes sweet pineapple and lime with vanilla. It gets its strong heat from Carolina Reaper peppers. Perfect for people who like sweet fruit with lots of spice.

Best Pairing: Cajun Chicken, Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket

Deep Canyon Co. Sizzlin’ Scorpion Scorching Hot Sauce (Heat Scale: 8)

First, you taste spices, then feel scorpion and habanero peppers hit your throat in this powerful sauce. As it is made with two of the hottest peppers and spices, it is perfect for those who like spicy food.

Best Pairing: Firehouse Meatball, Turkey & Cranberry

Firehouse Subs Sauces – Review

How To Choose The Right Sauce?

Choosing the best sauce depends on your taste preference. However, you can try these combinations:

For spice lovers, I would recommend Deep Canyon Co. Sizzlin’ Scorpion Scorching Hot Sauce or Florida Man’s Lunacy Pineapple Hot Sauce.
For a tangy kick, Spicy Mustard or Frank’s RedHot ® are great picks.
For a sweet and smoky touch, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce or Fat Cat Peach Maple Bourbon Hot Sauce is the way to go.
For a creamy texture, Firehouse Mayo is a must-try.

Check also: Firehouse Subs Gluten-Free

Infographic showing all sauces of Firehouse

How To Use Firehouse Subs Sauces

Firehouse Subs sauces are versatile and can be used in many ways. Here are a few ideas:

On Your Sub: The most common way to enjoy these sauces is by spreading them directly on your sub. They add moisture and flavor, making each bite more enjoyable.
As a Dipping Sauce: If you prefer to dip your sub, these sauces are perfect. They can also be used for dipping fries, onion rings, or other sides.
In Recipes: Get creative and use Firehouse Subs sauces in your home cooking. They can be used as marinades, salad dressings, or even as a topping for grilled meats.

Tips For Pairing Sauces With Subs

Meatball Sub: Pick marinara sauce, or try BBQ sauce for something new.
Turkey Sub: Choose honey mustard or ranch to enhance without overpowering.
Chicken Sub: Pick chipotle mayo, buffalo sauce, or ranch based on your spice level.
Steak Sub: Add BBQ sauce or chipotle mayo for a smoky flavor.
Veggie Sub: Use ranch or honey mustard to boost flavor.

Read also: Firehouse Subs Catering Menu

FAQs- Frequently Asked Questions

Firehouse Subs’ Captain Sorensen’s Datil Pepper Hot Sauce is the most selling item. When you put it on your sandwiches, you will feel its sweet and tangy flavor.

Yes, the brand provides sauces to its customers available in their stores at reasonable prices. You can also order online using their official website.

If you are looking for the hottest sauce, Firehouse Subs’ Deep Canyon Co. Sizzlin’ Scorpion sauce will not disappoint you. The scorpion and habanero peppers in it make your taste buds super spicy.

Yes, a sauce bar with a variety of 13 different sauces provides you an opportunity to taste and buy one that you like the most. All kinds of sauces, from mild ones to very hot ones are there at Firehouse Subs Hot Sauce Bar.

Yes, you can customize the sauces according to your taste. The worker at the desk can help you how to make a perfect combination.

Wrapping It Up

Firehouse Subs’ sauces make every sandwich taste better. For spicy food lovers, they have super hot sauces with scorpion and habanero peppers. For sweet tastes, try their honey or fruit sauces. There are also tangy ones with mustard and vinegar. Each sauce is special, and you can mix them to create your own favorite flavor. Next time you eat there, be sure to try some new sauces on your sandwich.